A Wrinkle In Time: Movie Review

In January, the book club my older daughters are in read A Wrinkle In Time by Madeleine L’Engle. I was thrilled, as this book had a tremendous impact on me at my oldest daughter’s exact age. Our discussion of the book was fantastic. It was exciting to see a new generation of girls inspired by Meg and reveling in L’Engle’s writing. I was encouraged and energized by their insights, observations, and questions.

It was perfect timing, then, that only two months later the movie was coming out.

With great anticipation, the parents took the book club kids to see said movie last night. We had a wonderful time taking up one and half rows of the theater and settling in to experience this story together again, in an entirely new way.

And now, I have some thoughts! A lot of them.

I went into this movie with hopeful and high expectations, which, admittedly, is always questionable practice where book adaptations are involved. I came out of the movie with an overall feeling of disappointment. Maybe my expectations were too high. Maybe I care about this particular story too much. Maybe I am too critical. Or maybe, just maybe, yet again, THEY MESSED UP!

I will go into as much detail as I can, without being spoilery, about the ways I think that happened. But in fairness, let me start with what I did like:

  • The casting of Meg. Storm Reid did an excellent job portraying Meg’s angst, confusion, frustration, suspicion, hope, disappointment, strength, and loyalty. Her performance was believable, thoroughly engaging, and true to L’Engle’s character. I was also pleasantly surprised by how well the casting of Mr. and Mrs. Murray worked. Gugu Mbatha-Raw and Chris Pine did a great job capturing their dynamic.
  • The diversity of the cast. Diverse representation in the fantasy/sci-fi genres has been sorely lacking, in print and in film. I was very pleased with Ava Duvernay’s decision to use such a diverse cast. This was particularly important in the casting of Meg. I love the fact that young black girls can go see a movie where they are represented as the smart, capable, beautiful heroine.
  • The scenes between Meg and Mr. Murray. Predictably, these scenes had a personal effect on me, remembering my dad and our dynamic. Those moments the two of them had together were among the most poignant, heartfelt scenes of the movie. I was very nervous about the casting of Chris Pine as a father, but I have to say, he did an excellent job, particularly in one of the most important moments of the story. I cannot give much more detail, but, surprisingly, one of my favorite moments in the book, also happened to be my favorite moment in the movie!
  • Mrs Whatsit’s opening line. While, arguably, too cheerfully delivered, it was an excellent homage to one of literature’s finest opening lines.
  • The way tessering was visualized. That was cool looking. I always had a difficult time picturing what that would look like. I thought the way they choose to depict it did justice to the book.
  • The IT. This was one of the very few changes that I thought actually worked well. Without giving anything away, let me just say, the movie version definitely portrayed the power and inescapableness of IT. I thought it was a good change.
  • The depiction of the darkness. This was especially well done during the explanation of what the darkness is while visiting the Happy Medium (but don’t even get me started on that portrayal…).
  • Sade’s new son “Flower of the Universe.” As a huge, long-time fan of Sade, I was very pleasantly surprised to hear her voice singing during the movie. Her new song is beautiful and fit perfectly.

Okay, *deep breath,* and now to the problems, at least as I see them:

  • Mrs Who. As my favorite Mrs. from the books, I was very excited to see how she would be played by Mindy Kaling. Unfortunately, it was not good. As I have thought about it overnight, I do not think it was her acting of the character that bothered me so much as the writing for her character. Mrs. Who’s deep, thoughtful, prophetic insights were “updated” into, often one word, attempted, mic-drops. This is not who Mrs. Who is. Her character is not an exclamation point. Her quotes are meaningful, inspiring, and thought-provoking. “DANG” just does not quite get at that with any semblance of responsible justice to the book. I do not have a problem with using quotes from more current sources as a way to reach a broader audience, so long as those quotes are in the same vein of depth as the originals. Sadly, more often than not, this was not the case. At. All. Not to mention that it is one of the most enduring qualities of L’Engle’s writing, that she does not assume she needs to use easy-to-access, tweetable, shortened quotes to read a broad audience. She believed in challenging her readers, stretching them. And it worked. I just watched it happen in January, with a group of elementary school age kids.
  • Mrs Whatsit. The re-writing of this character, and quite frankly, Resse Witherspoon’s portrayal of her, are a complete mystery to me, and not in a good way. How a supportive, kind, helpful, mysterious, measured character like L’Engle’s Mrs Whatsit can be re-worked into the silly, sarcastic, disingenuous character I saw last night, I will never know. It is very, very disappointing.
  • Mrs Which. I actually really like Oprah’s performance as Mrs Which. I will say though, IIIIII waaaasssss waaiittttinngggg ttoooo heeaarrrr sooommeeeonnne ppppuuuulllll oooofff hhhheeerrr waayyy oofffff sssppppeeaaakkiinnnggg. But again, no.
  • The changes. As someone who believes that books become beloved and well-known for the way the author told the story, I still cannot understand why screenplay adapters decide to change story details that could easily be translated into movie form. I understand that, for time’s sake, many parts of a story lay on the cutting room floor. What I am talking about are the changes to plot lines they are already choosing keep in the movie and are using CGI for, yet still change. It drives me insane every time and this time was no exception.
  • Camazotz. This was a whole lot of nope, nope, nope-ity, NOPE! There were two parts that were excellently done and, not surprisingly, followed the book’s description almost verbatim, but the rest was just terrible. I do not know how to go into the details of how it was so terrible without giving away story lines, but suffice it to say, in my view, this could not have been done worse. Two of their experiences on Camazotz were, actually, directly opposite to how it should have been.
  • What was left out. In my opinion, the “powers that be,” in the making of this movie, decided to leave out the most crucial part of the whole book. It’s just skipped over, not there at all, left completely out. I am sure that they would say it was for time’s sake, but I am guessing (and this may be my overally cynical side showing) that the actors playing the various Mrs were contracted for so many minutes “onscreen” and to accommodate the big names, they left a MAJOR part of the story, and my favorite character, out. I hope that is not true, but it does not make any sense otherwise. Let me just say this, I could have used A LOT less Uriel and A LOT more, or any really, of a certain Beast and her planet.

So there you have it, my, mostly unfiltered, thoughts.

Overall, if you haven’t read the book, it is a good movie. And, even if you have read the book, I would still say go see it. But then, immediately, go home and reread the book. It is, yet again, proven: the book is always better.




Guest Blogger: Mysterious Benedict Society

Hello everyone, I am writing to tell you that the Mysterious Benedict Society books are very, very enjoyable, must read, can’t-put-down books. When I was reading them I felt as if I was right there in the story. You know the feeling, right?

The first book of the trio, The Mysterious Benedict Society, is about two girls and two boys. They are brilliant and creative kids, who have a lot of potential. They are enjoyable characters and are really fun to learn, think, and read along with. Even though it is only the beginning of their story, it is still an amazing book!

The second book of the trio, The Mysterious Benedict Society and the Perilous Journey, is a very good, spur-of-the-moment book. As you follow the characters through the story of their second year together, you will find that not only do you fall in love with reading about them, but you also become more curious about what will happen next. As you may know, that is what makes books so hard to put down.

The third book in the trio, The Mysterious Benedict society and the Prisoner’s Dilemma, is a cutting edge story that I wish could go on forever! It is an amazing third book for the trio and it shows how far the characters have come from book one. I have so much thanks for the final and best book of the series, that it cannot be fully expressed in words, but simply I really, really, really loved the Mysterious Benedict Society series, but mainly The Mysterious Benedict Society and the Prisoner’s Dilemma.

There is so much more I wish that I could say, but I will not spoil anything at all. In conclusion, I really, really enjoyed reading The Mysterious Benedict Society. Thank you Trenton Lee Stewart!!!!

5 Best Apps for Tracking Reading

This week I have been challenged. It was not actually a new challenge, but one I was pushed to realize I had not followed through on at all. Not unlike determining our family would try one new recipe a week, or deciding that the chore charts would actually be put to use, or no longer drinking carbonated beverages. It is a recurring problem I have, the whole “follow through” thing.

Lately, I have a growing sense of foreboding in regards to the amount of time I waste on social media sites. I won’t even try to pretend that I don’t love social media, because I do. Social media sites are an introverts dream. I get to “interact” with the world from the comfort of my couch. I can keep in touch with people who are hundreds, even thousands of miles away. I can consume mass amounts of information, real and false, about the world, those dear to me, and the place I once called home. Except, I have felt my tenuous hold on the balance between real life and virtual life slipping ever so slightly.

Then came the challenge. In an article for the Washington Post titled “The Death of Reading is Threatening the Soul,” Philip Yancey discusses how the internet has trained his mind against disciplined reading. This excellent treatise on the distracted mind.

Charles Chu calculates that at an average reading speed of 400 words per minute, it would take 417 hours in a year to read 200 books—less than the 608 hours the average American spends on social media, or the 1,642 hours watching TV. “Here’s the simple truth behind reading a lot of books,” says Quartz: “It’s not that hard. We have all the time we need. The scary part—the part we all ignore—is that we are too addicted, too weak, and too distracted to do what we all know is important.” Willpower alone is not enough, he says. We need to construct what he calls “a fortress of habits.”


If I were to spend even half the time I spend on the internet reading or writing instead, I would recover many hours. These recovered hours would do wonders for my soul. But because of my aforementioned struggle with follow through, I realized that I would need assistance building my “fortress of habits.”

To find that assistance, I started looking for apps that would allow me to track reading times and scan books read. Chances are you are probably already well aquainted with “the big 4:” Amazon Kindle, Overdrive, Audible, and Goodreads. While I use each of these apps almost daily and appreciate the different features they offer, I wondered what else was “out there.” I thought I had found an excellent app, only to find out it no longer exists. So I kept looking.

Here are my thoughts on what I found.


  • Kobo – My favorite feature of this app is the “Reading Activity” section. It is just what I have been looking for. I have high hopes for this app.
  • Bookopolis – For kids, this is by far the best reading app I have come across. I haven’t been able to find an Android version of the app yet. But what I have seen of it for iPhone/Pad users looks excellent. It also has timing, record keeping features, as well as many, many book lists. Even if you don’t use the app, their website is a must use site.

Best with Monthly Fees:

  • Epic! – This app looks like the dream. There is a flat fee of $7.99 a month. With that you are able to set up four individual accounts, track each account’s reading progress, and access thousands of books. If I were going to pay a monthly fee for an app, this would be the one. Teachers, you are able to use this app without the monthly fee!
  • BookMate – I really liked the features this app has. If you are looking for an audiobook reader, this is a very good one. There is a monthly fee of $9.99 though and that seems a bit high for what they offer.

Best Basics:

  • Reading Log – There is nothing fancy about this app. In fact one of the biggest complaints about it is the interface and outdated appearance. But with that aside, if you are looking for an app to track your reading, Reading Log does that. It is easy to use and doesn’t waste time with the frills.

While falling down the rabbit hole that is any internet search, I discovered a great deal about book related apps. For example, did you know that if you are an Amazon Prime member you have access to free, yes free, streaming of books and podcasts on Audible? If you sign into Audible with your Amazon sign in and then go to Audible “Channels,” you have access to free streaming of any of the books and podcasts there!

Now to climb out of the rabbit hole and follow through!




Guest Blogger Review – Mercy (age 10): A Series of Unfortunate Events

In my opinion, A Series of Unfortunate Events is a really good series. Lemony Snicket did a very good job on these books. You may have heard of them. If you haven’t read the books, I recommend reading them.

The main characters are Violet, Klaus, Sunny, and Count Olaf. Violet, Klaus, and Sunny are the Baudelaire siblings. Count Olaf is the villain in the books and is always chasing the siblings around in order to get their fortune. The question is, can the Baudelaire siblings use their special abilities to not get put into Count Olaf’s clutches?

Although all the books are good, there are a couple that seem to drag on; but you should stick with them because they play parts in some of the later books. Don’t stop because you think that the books get worse because the last four books are the best.


My favorite books are books 10, 11, 12, and 13. Book 10 is called The Slippery Slope, book 11 is called The Grim Grotto, book 12 is called The Penultimate Peril and book 13 is called The End. I like book 10 because Sunny learns a new skill and passes out of babyhood. Also the Baudelaire siblings learn about a secret organization. I enjoyed book 11 because they meet a girl and her stepfather. They go into a grim grotto to find something and then they have to save Sunny. But I won’t tell you how because then I would spoil the suspense of it. So if you want to find out, you will have to read the series. Book 12 was good because they meet up with characters they met previously. They go to a hotel and have to solve problems for people at the hotel. Finally, book 13, my personal favorite, was a good book because they meet up with a friend from the hotel and have to solve problems on the island that they get ship wrecked on.

*Warning! Warning! Warning!* These stories are not as happy as other books and good things don’t happen as often as in some other books, but they are still really good. Therefore, I really suggest reading A Series of Unfortunate Events. They are amazing books, and very well written. Thank you, Lemony Snicket.


Trusted Favorites: Patricia Polacco

When you come across a children’s literature author with over 50 books to her credit, you expect that the author writes serialized books, the likes of Curious George, Franklin, and Berenstain Bears. You expect a few of the books to lack the luster of the others. You expect to tire of the author’s voice. In all these ways and more, Patricia Polacco exceeds expectation. She has written well over 50 individualized books, each one desirable, thoughtful, and her style and writing are a joy to read again and again.

I was recently reminded of the gift Polacco’s writing is to children’s literature when I found a book in the library by her that I had not read before. We checked it out and as soon as we got home, all sat down and read Mr. Lincoln’s Way. Although written sixteen years ago, Mr. Lincoln’s Way is an extremely timely and significant book. For any parent or teacher looking for tangible, sincere ways to discuss the racial tensions present in our world, this is an excellent book to start with. By the end, many of us were in tears (myself included) and we were all silent for several minutes after the book was finished. A reaction I have come to expect from a Patricia Polacco book.

Her stories are steeped in the muck and mire of harsh realities, realities she does not back away from. Instead, she writes a path of hope, unity, and acceptance right through the muck. At the end of her books, you will find yourself deep in thought: thinking about the nuanced difficulties of our world, thinking about your part in creating or abating those difficulties, and thinking about how grateful you are that someone gives voice to these issues in a way that communicates to children and adults alike.

My personal favorites from the Patricia Polacco collection are John Philip Duck, The Bee Tree, The Lemonade Club, Thank you, Mr. Falker, and now Mr. Lincoln’s Way. As soon as I am back at the library, I will be checking out Pink and Say to read next. With so many excellent books to her name, every reader’s favorites list will differ and I would love to hear what yours would include.





Representation Matters

Olympic swimming is one of the most popular events to watch. This week, here in the United States, we sat around our screens enthralled by Simone Manuel and her amazing talent in the pool. But her comments out of the pool that have been even more inspiring. After winning her first individual gold medal and becoming the first African American woman to do so, she said

“It means a lot, I mean, this medal is not just for me. It’s for a whole bunch of people who have came before me and have been an inspiration to me…and for all the people after me who believe they can’t do it and I just want to be an inspiration to others that you can do it.”

Representation matters.

It matters for athletes, it matters for scientists, it matters for voters, and it matters for students. To be inspired to dream and imagine and fully immerse themselves in a story children must be able to picture themselves in that story, to be represented there. As I watch Simone Manuel capture the imagination and inspiration of so many children this summer, I am reminded how strong that need for representation is in all parts of life, including children’s literature.

Representation matters.

It matters for people of color to see themselves in the imaginary world of dragon slaying princesses and super powered heroes, or in the ordinary world of playground drama and sibling rivalry and fun-loving adventure. It matters for white kids to see all of their fellow students, teammates, and neighbors represented equally in the literary world so there can be no room for exclusivity to become normative. So that even if they live in a place predominately white, they grow up connected to stories that diversify and normalize the world around them.

Representation matters. And here are some excellent places to start.

Coretta Scott King Awards – The American Library Association says:

“The awards are given annually to outstanding African American authors and illustrators of books for children and young adults that demonstrate an appreciation of African American culture and universal human values.  The award commemorates the life and work of Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., and honors his wife, Mrs. Coretta Scott King, for her courage and determination to continue the work for peace and world brotherhood.”

#1000BlackGirlBooks – Marley Dias, an 11 year old girl, was frustrated that she was unable to find books with main characters that looked like her. She created the #1000BlackGirlBooks hashtag on Twitter as a way of discovering book options with protagonists that are black girls. It has been and continues to be a very successful campaign and an extremely valuable resource.

everydaydiversity.blogspot.com – I came across this excellent blog accidentally while reading deep into the comments section of a different blog and  I am thrilled to have found it. It is a blog dedicated to recommending and reviewing children’s books with people of color as the main characters. It is a fantastic site.

Ezra Jack Keats – Everyday kids doing everyday things. This is what Keats excels at writing about and showing.

Kadir Nelson – Author/illustrator extraordinaire, Nelson’s books are thoughtful, historical, and beautiful. You should read them all.

Marti Dumas – Dumas gives her readers characters that are hilarious, adventurous, and witty. Her books should be on every child’s shelf.

Jacqueline Woodson – Jacqueline Woodson gives voice to older kids with her books for middle grade and young adult students. She has won many, many, many awards for her excellent writing, including a Newberry Award for Brown Girl Dreaming.

Proactive representation. This is one way we, as adults, can cultivate children’s imagination, inspire them, and dare our children to dream . It can start with books.

Diverse representation in children's literature is vital for children of all backgrounds. Here is a guide to some excellent authors and resources that provide that diversity through books.

Guest Student Blogger: Mercy (age 9)

I have just read the first Harry Potter book, The Sorcerer’s Stone. I really liked it and this is why. The book is so interesting. I really liked it! Let me tell you why the book is so interesting.

I love it when Hagrid tells Harry that he is a wizard! Then he starts at Hogwarts, a school for wizards and witches. It is funny when Hagrid and Harry try to hatch a forbidden dragon named, Norbert, in Hagrid’s wooden hut. I also think it is interesting when Harry gets past the black fire and finds Professor Quirrell.

Harry’s friends are Ron and Hermione. My favorite thing about Ron is that he is the first one to make friends with Harry right away. My favorite part with Hermione is when she helps Ron and Harry defeat a full grown mountain troll.

I also, like the Quidditch matches where Harry got to be a Seeker and catch the Snitch. It is cool when Harry got on the Quidditch team and got the really nice broomstick as a first year, which had not happened in a century at Hogwarts. It is also fun when Harry won the House Cup for Gryffindor, his house.

My favorite character is Harry Potter. This is why, he is the most important and interesting. The story would not have been very fun without him.

Harry is a hero!

Dear America

I am taking that first step down a slippery slope. That first step is entirely avoidable but oh so satisfying. I am, in full awareness, going to write a blog post detailing books about the United States of America for the 4th of July. It is so cliche I was not going to do it and still so perfect I cannot help myself.

The logic is sound. There is a series largely about U.S. history that I want to talk about but never seem to fit in anywhere until my sister pointed out that there is an entire upcoming holiday celebrating U.S. history. Perfect.

Until the blog becomes:

  1. 5 Perfect Books for Arbor Day
  2. 10 Amazing Books for World Pancake Day
  3. 3 Fantastic Books for Wheat Day
  4. 10 Incredible Books for National Donut day
  5. 100 Million Super Books for World Chocolate Day

The slippery slope. (Also, apparently I am hungry). It is too easy but, occasionally, appropriate to connect dates and events with books about those dates and events. I will do my best to use this crutch wisely and sparingly.

To that end, let me introduce you to the Dear America series. In this historical fiction series, events are chosen from U.S., and sometimes world, history and told through the diaries of a fictional girl from that time. The stories are fascinating, challenging, and compelling. The way they are told brings history to life in a new way for kids. They are able to sympathize with and imagine the stories so much more because they are told from a child’s point of view. For your child who is interested in history, these are a must read.

There are two spinoff series from the Dear America books. First is My Name is America; the stories in this series are told through the diaries of a fictional boy. The second series, called The Royal Diaries, takes historic queens from around the world and tells their childhood stories through fictional diaries.

At the end of each book, there is a historical note. These notes give a general history lesson about life and the major events during the time the story takes place. The books are an excellent introduction to historical events and figures that have helped shaped the United States of America, for good or for ill.



New Favorites: Author Edition

You know those moments when you are reading and the way an author turns a phrase has you re-reading the sentence just to appreciate it or an author creates a character so believable that you feel like you have met an actual person (only to have  people say insane things to you like, “Christy, you do realize Sirius is a work of fiction, right?”)? Recently, I had these moments with a new-to-me author.

Marti Dumas writes in a way that connects; she connects you to words and characters and leaves you searching Amazon for everything she has ever written. Her writing style is funny, witty, thoughtful, and engaging for children and adults. She has created a character who loves ninja dancing, she has embedded Dr. Who references in her writing, and she has written a blog post titled “Be like Stephen King”. If you have not stopped reading this and started searching Amazon yet, go ahead, I’ll wait.

She has introduced the world to a fantastic character in Jaden Toussaint. I have found myself, repeatedly, reading about his adventures on my own.  Jaden is a young boy who is all about exploration, experiments, and excitement while being raised in a family of readers.  His interactions with his family are genuine and hilarious. The way Dumas describes Jaden’s problem solving process is excellent.  In an amazing turn of events, the first book about Jaden called Jaden Toussaint, The Greatest: Episode 1 The Quest for Screen Time, is free on Amazon right now. So far, there are 3 episodes about Jaden Toussaint, The Greatest.

Dumas has also written the longer chapter book, Jala and the Wolves.  Jala is a 6 year girl who is about to have an unexpected adventure.  This is a book that your children will thoroughly enjoy reading on their own, but you will find yourself inventing reasons to read it to them (despite all the boxes of silent reading they need to check off for their homework).  She also has the upcoming chapter book called, Jackie’s Dragon, and considering the author and the fact that a little girl is interacting with a dragon, I have no doubt it will be fantastic.

New Favorites

It feels unfair to the old standbys, the Corduroys, Red Wagons, Freight Trains, and Snowy Days,  to start off my book recommendations with a book I read for the first time last week. I can’t help myself, the new book is too good to be put in line.  And so I begin with a new favorite.

With it’s opening sentences, “Morris Lessmore loved words.  He loved stories. He loved books.”, I was immediately drawn to William Joyce‘s The Fantastic Flying Books of Mr. Morris Lessmore.  Every part of this book, the words, the illustrations, the story, even the layout of the sentences, fits together perfectly.  The cover, with the look of perplexed surprise on Morris’ face, the name “Lessmore”, the heartbreaking but peaceful plot, they are all brilliant.

The story follows Morris Lessmore through a series of events ranging from ordinary where he “writes one orderly page after another”, to devastating in which “every story has its upsets”, to magical where he meets a woman “being pulled along by a festive squadron of flying books” (I mean, really…that sentence!) until he finally finds his place in, where else but, a library.  Here he discovers that “each book was whispering and invitation to adventure.”

And what could be more true about books than that!  May your adventures begin “with the opening of a book.”